Jürgen Stark: “In Argentina the economy will contract by more than 10% this year and the social situation is still deteriorat…”
Said 06 Sep 2002 (date) · Deutsche Bundesbank. Checked 14 Nov 2026 against official data: did not come true.
Did not come true. Said: economic growth above 10% in 2002. Official figure for Argentina: -10.9% (World Bank open data). Missed. Off by 20.9 points. official data · checked 14 Nov 2026 · automatic check against official data (rules v3)
What was said
The generally positive development in Asian and European emerging markets stands in stark contrast to recent events in Latin America. In Argentina the economy will contract by more than 10% this year and the social situation is still deteriorating dramatically. The situation in Brazil remains of particular concern, even after the announcement of a new IMF package.
Source: Cyclical and architectural issues of the international economy · Internet Archive copy · the official figure
How it was checked
Checked on 14 Nov 2026 (automatic check against official data (rules v3)). The published rules.
- Rated πρόγνωσις (prognōsis - inference from evidence): it is inferred from data, figures or trends.
- Counted as a forecast: it speaks about the future and gives a date, a likelihood or a figure.
- Deadline 31 Dec 2002: read from the words “this year”.
- Likelihood about 85%: our published table reads the word “will” as this number.
- Implied call / likelihood: Yes · 85% - for the most part (85% confident in the call).
- RIM-1 standard: not met - ATHENA would not file a call worded like this (it needs a defined event, a date, a stated likelihood, a measurable outcome and no hedging).
- Based on data: it mentions figures, data or projections.
- Checkable score 3/4 - names the event: no; firm deadline: yes; likelihood: yes; measurable figure: yes.
- Ambiguity 36/100: counted from hedging words (may, could, gradually…) and from each missing element above.
Proof the record was not changed
Captured 13 Nov 2026 21:06 UTC. Fingerprint of the source text (SHA-256):
4e42cf88ac64c546a968d3fde907f633449cf39185c3a78760d2d2d6d624a937. The day's record was sealed on 2026-11-13 and anchored in Bitcoin block #975,763.
Full evidence page · Jürgen Stark: report card · Ask for a correction