Tommaso Padoa-Schioppa
European Central Bank
Track record: No forecast checked yet (13 not due, 29 being checked).
42forecasts & commitments on the record
36%can be checked as stated
40average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: based on data 30, stated on authority 6, educated guess 6.
Kinds of claim: forecast 30, scenario (if… then) 6, mixed claim 5, commitment 1. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence29 · 69%πρόνοιαPreparing for the future6 · 14%μαντείαInspired knowledge5 · 12%φρόνησιςPractical wisdom1 · 2%προαναγγελίαPublic pre-announcement1 · 2%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (42)
If lower tax rates in the new Member States were to put pressure for tax reform in the euro area, as the lower tax rates in Ireland have already done, this could only be for our benefit.
On the other hand, with more than 50% of total Russian trade being conducted with the EU it may be become increasingly suboptimal to expose Russia’s relative competitiveness vis-à-vis its major trading partner to fluctuations in the euro-US dollar exchange rate.
In late May this year we met for the first High-level Joint Eurosystem – Bank of Russia Seminar in Helsinki, where we discussed monetary and exchange rate policies, trade and financial links between our markets and developments in our domestic banking sectors.
Rising inflation rates, in particular if they are not clearly associated with GDP-per-capita convergence, could make the economies vulnerable to increasing inflation expectations and wage-price spirals.
Some impulses may in fact result from the catching up process and can therefore be regarded as equilibrium phenomena –“physiological” inflation, if I may – while other less benign pressures, for example resulting from overly buoyant domestic demand growth or by a premature “catching up” of the wage level – i.e. “pathological” inflation – would require a different response.
As traders would be reluctant to trade if they had doubts as to whether the trade will in fact settle, inefficiencies in this crucial infrastructure would ultimately be reflected in higher costs to issuers and lower returns to investors, which in turn will impede capital formation.
Moreover, foreign exchange markets – while having contracted in size, owing mainly to technology and banking concentration – have such a large turnover (around EUR 1,200 billion per day) that it is difficult to consider how relations between leading currencies might be organised otherwise.
While the initial depreciation of the euro against the US dollar may have restricted the use of the euro as a reserve currency, in 2001 and even more markedly this year market trends have favoured diversification towards the euro.
This is a field subject to a significant structural component, since energy and other commodities, representing 20% of total imports of the euro area, are most unlikely to change the currency (the US dollar) in which they are priced.
If they persist over time, they will support long-term growth, as the expansion of the banks' deposit base will also be conducive to underpinning financial intermediation.
Indeed, I am sure you will agree that the successful introduction of euro banknotes and coins this year has marked far more than the emergence of a new payment instrument.
The possible operational involvement of the Eurosystem is still under discussion as a medium-term option, not as an issue for 2002.
From 1 January 2002 the reduced reporting requirements will take effect and, hopefully, the MIF as well.
But we have strongly indicated that we expected customer fees to decrease substantially in 2002.
As to the political issue, citizens will be inevitably disappointed next year by the still high level of cross-border fees, but the regulation would clearly indicate that the situation is transitory.
In spite of this good news, in recent months two very negative indications from the private sector have increased our fears that the price objective will not be met in 2002: Firstly, banks have proposed that the MIF be set at 3 euro.
Citizens indeed expect that, from next year onward, cross-border transfers will be as speedy and inexpensive as domestic payments are today.
The second half of 2002 could be an appropriate point in time to undertake a new fully-fledged survey.
Undoubtedly, the cash changeover in 2002 will be another milestone in the evolution of correspondent banking business in Europe.
A further step towards higher concentration is expected in 2002 when the legacy currencies (which are still used for a large part of the commercial payments processed via correspondent banks) will cease to exist.
This will be all the more so from 2002 thanks to the introduction of euro banknotes and coins: for payments in central bank money, the distinction between domestic and cross-border payments will disappear once and for all.
The conclusions of the Nice Summit imply, it is fair to say, that the earliest date for new accessions to the EU is probably the beginning of 2005.
Second, because, if there remains a distinction between domestic and cross-border payments in the euro area after 2002, this will disappoint the expectations of European citizens.
For central bank money, the distinction between domestic and cross-border payments will disappear in early 2002.
That effort will make sure that, within the first few weeks of 2002, the currency borders for banknotes in the euro area will disappear.
On their side, central banks are producing an enormous effort to prepare the cash changeover (14 billion banknotes and 60 billion coins will have to be replaced, which represents 170 square kilometres of paper to be printed and 270,000 tons of metal to be minted).
In early 2002, however, the distinction between domestic and cross border payments will have to disappear.
This means that, after 2002, indifference between commercial bank money and central bank money will have to apply to the whole of Euroland.
However, in order to further clarify this mandate, and also to facilitate the external evaluation of the Eurosystem's performance, the ECB has adopted a quantitative definition of price stability: a year-on-year increase of the Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices of below 2%, to be achieved over the medium term.
In Italy and Germany, for instance, there are no more than half a dozen banks operating on a national scale, with an aggregate market share which probably amounts to less than 30% of the domestic market.
The results of this analysis are expected to become available by the end of this year. 31.
This explains the publication of a series of objectives that the banking community is invited to meet by 2002 at the latest, when all the day-to-day transactions of the citizens of the euro area will be denominated in euro.
They will continue to be the only legal tender for cash payments in the respective countries until 1 January 2002 , the deadline which will affect your citizens the most.
Contracts denominated in the former national currencies will be deemed to be in euro from January 2002 onwards, without any need for the parties to modify their legal terms.
Second , bank deposits in the former national currencies are de jure equivalent to deposits in euro at the irrevocable conversion rates; if this has not yet occurred, they will be automatically converted into euro on 1 January 2002 .
It has a vital interest in a stable and efficient banking industry; it is, therefore, keen to see its action complemented with an effective conduct of the supervisory functions by the competent authorities; it needs a clear and precise knowledge of the state of the euro area's banking industry as a whole and of its major individual players; and it …
In the short term, the structural adaptation process could be made more difficult by the combination of factors like the protracted financial difficulties of Asia and Russia, or the preparations for the year 2000.
The introduction of the euro will benefit the world economy if it contributes to higher growth in the euroland and to the maintenance of low inflation and interest rates.
Having consulted the ECB on a first draft, the ECOFIN Council will consider a new text in one of its forthcoming meetings in November or in December of this year.
Since the fourth Lomé Convention will expire in February 2000, the European Union and ACP countries started on 30 September 1998 negotiations regarding future arrangements.
Specifically, the CFA franc zone is forecast to grow at least 4.5% this year, while maintaining very low (by African standards) inflation rates: less than 5% in most of the 15 countries.
The groundwork for this change had been accomplished to some extent by the predecessor of the European Central Bank, the European Monetary Institute (EMI), which operated in Frankfurt from 1994 to 31 May this year.
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
It will be up to the national authorities to attain these important objectives in the coming years and to demonstrate that more radical solutions do not need to be envisaged.
The home authority, for example, needs to be adequately informed about developments in local establishments that might impact the whole group; similarly, the host authority needs to be informed about developments upstream in the group that might have a significant impact on its local financial system and may even affect its taxpayers in case of a failure.
It should not be forgotten, after all, that one of the conclusions of the Wise Men’s report stated that if the recommended approach did not succeed, it might be appropriate to consider a Treaty change, including the creation of a single EU regulatory authority for financial services in the Community.
Supervisory convergence will be one of the cornerstones to achieve this important objective.
Because I am a central banker and José María Roldan from the CEBS is one of our discussants, I will tackle this question especially from the angle of the banking sector.
In providing some food for the debate, I will first offer a brief overview of important developments that are taking place in the European banking sector.
In addition, and somewhat paradoxically, there were concerns in form of the question “will we cope?” relating to the fear that for the very affluent, and supposedly very orderly, economic and social system of western Europe, the accession of an entire population almost as large as that of Germany but with low wages, low living standards, a high level of …
If anything, one would expect the fears and reservations about migration to come from new EU members, not from the old ones.
But it should also be said that the grey market is often the symptom of an “official” labour market that is too rigid to function properly.
Arguments about unfair tax competition should not be used as a smokescreen to distract attention from what every citizen in the euro area knows: that tax regimes need to change, and fiscal pressure has to fall.
Other factors Labour mobility, industrial relocation and tax systems are among the major factors that need to be changed in western Europe, with the new ten being in the position to lead the change.
A widely shared assessment of both projects seems to be the following: much has been achieved, more needs to be done.