Spencer Dale
Central bank (via BIS)
Track record: No forecast checked yet (27 not due, 26 being checked).
53forecasts & commitments on the record
74%can be checked as stated
40average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: based on data 31, stated on authority 15, educated guess 7.
Kinds of claim: forecast 36, mixed claim 9, scenario (if… then) 6, commitment 2. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence28 · 53%μαντείαInspired knowledge13 · 25%πρόνοιαPreparing for the future6 · 11%εἰκασίαConjecture2 · 4%προαναγγελίαPublic pre-announcement2 · 4%πρόβλεψιςSeeing the signs2 · 4%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (53)
Consider next the reduction in economic uncertainty which has probably played a greater role in turning the economy around this year.
Most importantly, it will underpin further increases in house building, which has played an important role in driving the economic growth we've enjoyed this year and which, as a nation, we need to see.
consistently been set to ensure that inflation remains on track to return to the 2% target in the medium term.
Indeed, my colleague Ben Broadbent, in his former life as a city commentator, used to draw attention to the startling correlation between the behaviour of the MPC and movements in growth implied by business surveys. 7 The self-same surveys that are currently pointing to quarterly GDP growth of around 1%, a rate which in the past would have signalled the …
But returning inflation to the target too slowly might cause people to question the MPC's commitment to keep inflation close to 2% in the medium term.
But if, even as the recovery gathers pace, productivity growth remains relatively muted, unemployment will likely fall more quickly and the Committee will need to raise rates sooner.
And, on the basis of the MPC's central projection in the August Inflation Report, it is expected to remain above target until the second-half of 2015.
When we reach the 7% unemployment threshold, the Committee will reassess the state of the economy based on all available information and, on that basis, decide whether it should start to withdraw the current extraordinary levels of stimulus. 2
If that were the case, the economy could grow relatively rapidly, absorbing spare resources and capacity, without putting much upward pressure on wages and prices.
Based on the MPC's central projection for inflation published last month, over the decade to the end of 2015, CPI inflation will average close to 3%.
As such, inflation was expected to fall back to around the 2% target by the end of 2015.
Inflation was projected to rise further in the near-term - to above 3% in the second half of this year - and to remain above the 2% target for the next two years or so.
If labour hoarding and data revisions provide only a partial explanation of the recent sluggishness of productivity growth, what else might account for it?
If this weakening in the labour market continues that could materially change the relationship between output and employment.
If the LFS measure were revised towards Workforce Jobs, that could raise productivity per head by around 2 percentage points.
For example, if GDP were to be revised in line with the path the MPC judge most likely, that would account for only around one fifth of the 9% productivity shortfall. 7
But that decision will need to be weighed against the backdrop of continuing high inflation, with inflation set to climb higher over the next few months.
You may know that between February and August of this year, I was one of the members of the MPC that had been voting to raise Bank Rate.
Inflation is likely to fall back next year, as the temporary impacts from these factors wane and the persistent slack in our economy continues to pull down on inflation.
The rate of inflation expected over the next year or so may consistently move around since the MPC does not attempt to bring inflation back to target over very short time horizons.
This suggests that by mid 2012, inflation is likely to have been above target for the best part of six and a half years.
Inflation is likely to remain above target for the next year or so.
However, relative to the February 2009 forecast considered here, changes in VAT did not contribute significantly to the surprising strength of inflation in 2009/10, since the effects of the temporary reduction in VAT in December 2008 were included in that forecast, and the main impact of the more recent increase in VAT did not come through until the first quarter …
But with growth expected to be around its average historical rate, inflation likely to remain above 4% for the rest of this year and Bank Rate at record low levels, some withdrawal of policy stimulus seems sensible.
I predict that 2011 may be the year of macroprudential policy.
Unless or until effective instruments can be found to manage these other issues, vulnerabilities will remain, to which monetary policy will need to stay vigilant.
This missing instrument problem provides the backdrop to the Government's announcement earlier this year that it intends to create a new policy committee in the Bank - the Financial Policy Committee - which will have responsibility for conducting macroprudential policy.
Some rough back-of-the-envelope calculations suggest that of that 3.1%, increases in energy prices may have contributed between 0-0.5% points, the increase in VAT earlier this year 0.5-1% points and the increase in import prices associated with sterling's depreciation around 1-2% points.
And inflation is likely to remain above target throughout 2011, elevated by the increase in VAT to 20% at the beginning of next year.
If that were to happen, and wage and price setters started to expect higher inflation to persist, the task facing the MPC in returning our economy to an environment of low and stable inflation would be substantially greater.
CPI inflation has averaged close to 3% over the past four years, significantly higher than the 2% target and for the most part higher than the MPC anticipated.
The peak impact of the exchange rate depreciation on CPI inflation was probably somewhere in the range of 2 to 3 percentage points.
I will use this broad framework to consider why inflation has been above the 2% target for much of the past four years and why inflation was higher than expected for much of this period.
Yes: the period of above target inflation; the fact that inflation has been higher than expected; and that it is likely to remain above target until the end of next year all contribute to the risk that credibility and confidence in the MPC may start to waver.
We are likely to learn a lot about the transmission of those purchases and about their ultimate impact over the course of the next year.
The ultimate success of QE will depend on whether the monetary injection and increased asset prices stimulate nominal spending and so help achieve the 2% inflation target in the medium term.
A standard portfolio model of OFC's money demand, in which money holdings are jointly modelled with movements in asset prices and relative rates of return, would suggest that asset purchases on the scale seen might increase asset prices by the order of 20-30%. 4 At first blush, this impact may seem surprisingly large.
In a similar vein, although there has been a substantial fall in employment over the past year or so, the extent of the job losses to date has, if anything, been less than we might have feared given the falls in output.
These extraordinary actions were intended to reduce the risk of inflation falling below the 2% inflation target that the Bank of England is mandated to meet.
However, you may have noticed that there was a split vote amongst the Committee last month, and that I voted to maintain the scale of the asset purchase programme at £175 billion.
In facing these challenges, the Monetary Policy Committee will do whatever it takes to ensure that inflation remains on track to hit the target.
Although output is estimated to have contracted in the third quarter of this year, there is a range of evidence from business surveys, from the Bank's regional Agents, and from recent indicators that the economy has begun to stabilise and that we are likely to be moving into a period of renewed expansion.
Further out, the downward pressure from the persistent margin of spare capacity is likely to cause inflation to fall back below the 2% inflation target, although this pressure should gradually fade as the economy recovers.
But the Monetary Policy Committee stands ready to do whatever it takes to ensure that the economy moves into better balance and inflation remains on track to hit the target.
Although there has been a substantial fall in employment over the past year or so, the size of this adjustment to date has, if anything, been less than we might have feared given the falls in output.
In contrast, external estimates of the loss of supply capacity as a result of the recession, to which the fall in human capital is likely to be closely related, are around the 4-5% range.
Even if output does expand in the second half of this year, for many families and businesses it may still feel like we are in the economic doldrums.
And the most recent output data and business surveys suggest that we are likely to see positive growth in the second half of 2009.
The Bank has so far purchased a little over £96bn of assets and is on track to have purchased £125bn of assets by the end of July.
Committee judged it was more likely than not that CPI inflation would be below the 2% inflation target in two or three years time if interest rates followed a path implied by market yields and the stock of purchased assets increased to £125bn.
Showing the newest 50 - the ledger has all 53.
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
So there are good reasons for thinking that the reduced uncertainty may help to facilitate this handover to business spending we need to see, and that some of those effects may be long lasting.
Rather, our guidance should reassure you that, absent risks to either price stability or financial stability, we will tighten policy only when we are well along the road to recovery.
## Spencer Dale: The UK's economic recovery - why now; will it last; and what next for monetary policy?
Even more importantly, will the recovery last?
What should we make of the view, repeated in many quarters, that the trade off between growth and inflation may be unusually favourable in present circumstances.
But it also acknowledges that inflation will on occasions deviate from its target as a result of shocks and disturbances, and that '...attempts to keep inflation at the inflation target in these circumstances may cause undesirable volatility in output'. 1 Although the language is arcane, the meaning is clear: monetary policy should try to prevent damaging booms and busts in …
These global imbalances remain and are forecast to get bigger. 6 Macroprudential policy should mean that the tensions associated with these imbalances manifest themselves in different ways, in particular in ways that are less damaging to the stability of the banking system.
But it is possible that some of the risks will crystallise and policy will need to react.
But the structure of many traditional mortgage lenders' balance sheets meant that lowering Bank Rate even further was likely to eat into their profitability and so intensify the credit crunch.
Most UK government bonds are held by non-bank financial sector companies (OFCs), such as pension funds and insurance companies. 3 As long as these investors do not regard money as a perfect substitute for gilts, they will attempt to reduce the additional money holdings associated with gilt purchases by switching into other assets.
An important issue when thinking about the likely channels of monetary transmission is the state of the banking system.
I want to spend a little time today considering a third factor that will shape the recovery: the extent to which households need to rebuild their balance sheets following the big increase in household debt.