Sam Woods
Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) · GBR
Track record: No forecast checked yet (16 not due, 9 being checked).
25forecasts & commitments on the record
40%can be checked as stated
50average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: based on data 19, educated guess 4, stated on authority 2.
Kinds of claim: forecast 12, mixed claim 9, scenario (if… then) 4. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence18 · 72%πρόνοιαPreparing for the future4 · 16%μαντείαInspired knowledge2 · 8%εἰκασίαConjecture1 · 4%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (25)
And there is evidence that our deferral periods are longer than they need to be to create the right incentives for safety and soundness. 8 We will therefore bring forward proposals to reduce deferral periods, while making sure they remain long enough to promote financial stability.
Fintech, stablecoins and the like will only make a positive contribution to the economy if they can operate in a stable, highconfidence environment.
We will be bringing forward a comprehensive Basel 3.1 consultation by the end of this year.
We think that on recent economic conditions - specifically, those at both year-end 2020 and yearend 2021 - the amount of capital released would be equivalent to 10-15% of the current capital held by life insurers, which could support between £45b and £90b in additional investment in the economy.
also imagine that you can put funds somewhere without any risk and earn interest of 1%, and that the Solvency II rules say that for assets with the credit rating of these bonds we have to allow 0.5% per year to cover the risk of things going wrong.
Perhaps it's OK that the rules should allow an insurer to bank more up-front from the 5% bond, but we should also make a greater allowance for the possibility that some of that extra return on the 5% bond may be reward for a higher risk of things going wrong.
Like so many of the impacts of climate change, this cost would be borne unequally: 45% of the mortgage impairments in the scenario are accounted for by just 10% of the country. And there is evidence that in areas particularly at risk of flooding, many homes could become uninsurable.
Projected impairment rates for banks are up 50% compared with normal levels.
For example, projected climate-related bank credit losses were 30% higher in the LA scenario than the EA scenario.
You may find it counterintuitive that the 2050 temperature outcomes do not differ wildly across these two scenarios but that reminds us that changes in climate policy take a long time to feed through to climate outcomes.
Of course, even if buffers were cut to zero, there is a risk that banks will feel under pressure from the market to preserve their capital ratios in a stress.
In the Bufferati simplified bail-in debt requirements could either be driven by minimum requirements or, if that appeared too low, a simple % (such as 50%) of the entire going concern capital stack.
As an illustration - if you ran a macroeconomic analysis that said the average capital level should be 14%, then the supervisor might set the capital requirement for a firm with riskier exposures at 16%, while another lower-risk firm might get 12%, and so on.
Looking ahead the UK will host COP26 in November and we have an important deadline for PRAregulated firms to have embedded our supervisory expectations on managing climate-related financial risks by the end of the year.
There is also the risk that simplifying requirements for smaller firms could increase barriers to growth, if the step up to the next level of our framework is too big.
In particular the main event of this year: you may think it is defeating Covid, but of course it is in fact the review of Solvency II.
At the same time, in addition to the 'proportionality' problem we face the 'barriers to growth' problem - that if we strip parts of the regime away for small firms this will create new barriers for those firms as they grow out of the 'small' category and need to take on additional regulation. 5
The question is whether these netting benefits will prove robust in a major stress - if not, the aggregate leverage ratio for firms in our sample would fall by up to 70 basis points.
The first observation about this is that it will often create wrong-way risk because the value of the collateral may well be linked to the credit-worthiness of the borrower, which can cause problems in times of stress even though collateral haircuts tend to be 30-50%.
We encourage all firms to opt into the regime because it will provide certainty until March 2022, independent of the existence and duration of any wider implementation period.
Simply put, this will allow us to bridge incoming EU27 firms for three years from March of next year while they seek an authorisation to continue business in the UK.
You may be relieved to hear that, in my determination to be the Mansion House good cop this year, I will only touch on two examples of this - though each of them is a huge topic.
Our proposition is a simple one: house price growth above the risk-free rate is a risk to which ERM providers are exposed; it should not therefore be assumed and banked up-front as capital in the form of the Matching Adjustment, even if a reasonable person could expect house prices to increase in that way - instead, that benefit should be …
The new strategic plan that we have just adopted for the Bank ('Vision 2020') is exactly in this spirit and I'm delighted that my beady-eyed colleague Vicky Saporta will lead some horizon-scanning work in this area.
- a suspicion that we will somehow keep the current 'ICAS' regime alive after 1 January 2016, rather than embracing the new regime.
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
By the same token, just as healthy people may only see their doctor on occasion for a check-up and some healthy living advice, the intensity and focus of supervision should differ according to the health of the firm.
As the financial system and broader economy continue to evolve, supervisors will need to upskill across an even broader set of issues, with artificial intelligence, quantum computing, the evolution of market-based finance and geopolitics among the more salient examples today.
I suspect we will continue to ask a great deal of the supervisors of the future, as we do today, but in return the role offers continual learning, intellectual stretch, and the opportunity to exercise judgement on issues that matter deeply for economic and financial stability.
Indeed, what one might call the proto-regulators in the UK - the factory inspectorates and Justices of the Peace - performed such functions.footnote And to this day, a lot of regulation still looks like this - whether it is the Food Standards Agency, the Health & Safety Executive, or in some respects the police.
Supervisors not only monitor banks closely, they also use banks’ own governance and systems to detect and mitigate a wider range of issues than they could through supervision alone.
Without rules banks might reasonably argue that it is impossible to know what is expected of a regulated firm, as might the supervisors themselves.
Indeed, what one might call the proto-regulators in the UK the factory inspectorates and Justices of the Peace - performed such functions.6 And to this day, a lot of regulation still looks like this - whether it is the Food Standards Agency, the Health &
Supervisors not only monitor banks closely, they also use banks' own governance and systems to detect and mitigate a wider range of issues than they could through supervision alone.
But honestly if Parliament puts the word 'safety' into our primary objectives, then you should expect us to be proud growth-oriented safetyists!
At the same time, we will sometimes have to disagree with industry - as our job is to represent the interests of the public, and in particular to pursue our statutory objectives.
And we will also continue to liaise closely with the government, in particular with Treasury ministers who have an important role in setting the wider agenda and expecting us to deliver our part of it.
So coming back to our new objective, this much is simple - Parliament has spoken, and we will deliver.