Paul Fisher
Bank of England
Track record: No forecast checked yet (46 not due, 23 being checked).
69forecasts & commitments on the record
61%can be checked as stated
49average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: based on data 58, educated guess 7, stated on authority 4.
Kinds of claim: forecast 42, mixed claim 17, scenario (if… then) 8, commitment 2. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence53 · 77%πρόνοιαPreparing for the future8 · 12%μαντείαInspired knowledge3 · 4%προαναγγελίαPublic pre-announcement2 · 3%πρόβλεψιςSeeing the signs2 · 3%εἰκασίαConjecture1 · 1%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (69)
The liquidity requirements will be increased over time until the full requirement is in operation on by January 2019 at the latest.
From 1 January 2016 a new European-wide capital standard will come into force under the Solvency II directive.
CRDIV will take until 2019 to be fully implemented.
That is likely to continue to be the case until at least 2019.
From January 2016 the G-SIB buffers will range 0-2.5%, but with scope ta ga higher, and from 2019 the wider systemic risk buffer will range up to 3.0%.
'The Committee will (also) review a number of activities in the non-bank financial system over the next year, to consider potential systemic risks posed by: the investment activities of open-ended investment funds and hedge funds; securities financing transactions; the nontraditional, non-insurance and investment activities of insurance companies; and derivative transactions.
We are implementing new IT and data collection systems and will be ready to accept the submission data required under the directive from June 2015.
That would likely necessitate wild swings in policy settings: imagine the MPC trying to set Bank Rate so that 2% inflation was achieved exactly every month!
3 In addition to Mark Carney as Governor, the proposed internal members from May 2015 will be Andrew Bailey as Deputy Governor and CEO of the PRA;
And the strategic changes internally at the Bank announced earlier this year could be seen as being a reinforcement to that structure by maximising the synergies across the Bank, including the PRA.
A conservative extrapolation of the pre-crisis trend would suggest that UK output is some 15-20% below where it would have been expected to be by this time in the absence of the crisis.
It is very difficult to anticipate the precise trajectory of prices and we have certainly learned more about the dynamics of inflation during this difficult period: the effects of the 25% depreciation in the sterling effective exchange rate between mid-2007 and early 2009 were larger and longer-lasting than we anticipated for example 3 .
Although we can't expect inflation to be exactly 2.0% very often (just four times since it was announced as the target variable in December 2003), inflation has been above target for most of the past six years.
But the inflation target remains our primary objective and we will have to be careful not to allow pressures to build up from excess demand.
The MPC has been clear all along, that upon reaching the 7% threshold we will have to consider what the medium-term pressures on the economy are and make an appropriate judgement about the direction and pace of policy, and any further guidance that we may choose to issue in future.
For example, the Bank's latest public survey shows a marked reduction in the proportion of people expecting a rise in interest rates over the next year - it's currently the lowest reading since Bank Rate was cut sharply in late 2008 at the height of the financial crisis.
- if, in the MPC's view, it is more likely than not, that CPI inflation 18 to 24 months ahead will be 0.5 percentage points or more above the 2% target;
The MPC stands ready to undertake further asset purchases while the unemployment rate remains above 7% if it judges that additional monetary stimulus is warranted but will otherwise maintain the stock of asset purchases and will reinvest the cash flows associated with all maturing gilts held in the Asset Purchase Facility.
But if even only a small part could be recovered then output should be able to grow strongly for some years without generating much inflationary pressure.
Much has been made of the market reaction to forward guidance since its launch, with market prices currently implying that Bank Rate will rise by 25 basis points by the middle of 2015, around six months earlier than at the time of our August meeting.
In case that's not sufficiently simple, let me put it the other way round: we remain committed to returning CPI inflation to its 2% target in line with our remit but, in doing so, we will not act in a way which would risk choking off the recovery prematurely, given the potential for a substantial amount of spare capacity in …
If monetary policy is limited in terms of its ability to generate growth, what else could we do to support the real adjustment of the economy?
If we push too much money into the system, the risk would be that it does nothing for real output, which is being driven by real adjustments, instead it could just end up in higher inflation.
The MPC is committed to getting inflation back to around the 2% target - which it will in due course, in the absence of further shocks and if we are careful with policy.
To be clear, we do not need to be 100% finished before growth strengthens at all, and we may be beginning to see some signs of a pick-up.
Nearly 50% of bank and building society lending to corporates is to the property sector and a good part of the rest will be secured on property.
These prices - which are about 16% of the CPI basket will contribute around one percentage point to the CPI inflation rate in the next couple of years, largely regardless of what happens to domestic demand.
Given the shocks that have hit the UK since 2008, and the dependence of the UK on financial services, output could have fallen much, much further than the 6% fall from peak to trough that is actually recorded, and the unemployment rate could easily have peaked well into double figures instead of the 8 ½% that actually transpired.
For example, if people believe that inflation will be 2% in the medium term, and act accordingly, it is much more likely that inflation will stay close to 2% in practice without big swings in monetary policy.
many parts of the economy had become over-extended: some UK commercial banks are still rebuilding their balance sheets; the Government will take several more years to rebalance expenditure and income; households are still increasing savings rather than spending in aggregate; and some corporates are reluctant - or unable - to take on new debts.
I should also note that, from April 1st this year, the new Financial Policy Committee (the FPC) of the Bank will also have statutory responsibility and powers to make the financial system more resilient through macroprudential policies ,4 and the Prudential Regulation Authority (the PRA) within the Bank of England will take over from the Financial Services Authority the job …
If a firm's lending stock contracts, however, they can only access up to that 5% allocation and the price of the scheme will also be higher - rising linearly to a maximum of 150 basis points if their lending contracts by 5% or more.
If banks hold more capital than they did pre-crisis and are less levered, then they will be in a more secure position to provide credit to support the real economy.
That said, it will probably take some time for banks to review fully their lending plans, and it is likely that drawings from the FLS will be spread out over the full window to end-2013.
Every firm that signs up to the FLS will be able to borrow an amount equal to at least 5% of their initial stock of lending on a standard definition for which the Bank already collects data. 4 If the firm expands its lending over the period until end-2013, they will be able to borrow an equivalent additional amount too.
In addition, we will publish the first set of drawdown data in December, although you will have seen that one bank has already announced that it has drawn £1bn and plans to draw more.
We will charge a fee of just 25 basis points per annum as long as a bank's stock of lending does not contract over the period to end 2013.
After applying appropriate haircuts to each piece of collateral pre-positioned, this means the Bank could, subject to solvency and viability assessments and repayment plans, lend around £160bn in the DWF without the complications of further detailed collateral checks. 11 Although not a substitute for firms
As an example, if you stress test a 30-40% fall in US residential real estate prices and that shows your institution would be in trouble, you need to make consistent assumptions about the deteriorating credit conditions of your counterparties, anyone that provides reinsurance and general market conditions.
We assert that, if one had stressed bank capital in the US with the explicit assumption that national residential real estate prices could go down 30 to 40%, and in some local markets more, most of the losses for US banks could have been correctly predicted (at least if the complexities of structured credit products were properly assessed 6 ).
Nonetheless, the rapid growth in ETF assets under management - which have increased seven-fold since 2003 ( Chart 15 ) - merit attention, given it has been characterised by increasing complexity, opacity and interconnectedness, and as some practices, if left unchecked, could grow to pose risks to the stability of the financial system. 12
For example, it has facilitated the remarkable pre-emptive reduction in the amount outstanding under the Bank's Special Liquidity Scheme (SLS), from around £90bn at end-February to just £37bn at the end of May ( Chart 9 ).
Updated to end-May 2011; recent months use 2011 Q1 GDP.
Chart 1 CPI inflation projection based on market interest rate expectations and £200 billion asset purchases
CPI inflation has been above its 2.0% target since December 2009, reaching 4½% in April and May 2011.
Moreover, the rate of inflation may well stay above target for the remainder of 2011 and 2012.
## Projection of the level of GDP based on market interest rate expectations and £200 billion asset purchases
Chart 1 GDP projection based on market interest rate expectations and £200 billion asset purchases
The MPC responded by cutting Bank Rate as low as it could reasonably go and injecting £200bn of extra money into the economy (14% of annual nominal GDP).
The largely unanticipated path of CPI inflation over the past couple of years can be explained by three factors: changes in the standard rate of VAT, unforeseen changes in wholesale oil and gas prices and higher-than-expected import prices following the 25% depreciation of sterling since mid-2007.
Showing the newest 50 - the ledger has all 69.
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
Indeed, where the PRA judges it is necessary to intervene, we will seek to do so at an early stage.
Firms should be open and straightforward in their dealings with the PRA and we in turn will take a risk-based and proportionate approach.
Insurers will need to deal with the PRA in an open, co-operative and constructive manner to allow us to understand whether the business model is sustainable and to identify key vulnerabilities.
Instead, the PRA will need to work with its regulated entities closely and early in the process of innovation.
Being a risk-based regime means that insurers should be able to evolve and adapt to capture all risks they are exposed to and the qualitative risk assessment introduced under Pillar II will further support this move towards a more responsive, reflective and adaptable solvency regime.
One such area where this should be borne in mind is in the use of risk models which will play a huge role in Solvency II for the larger, more complicated firms.
Transposition of Solvency II into the UK rulebook is underway and we will be open for applications for internal models, matching adjustment etc from April 1.
Changes to business models will naturally lead to changes in risk exposures which will need to be carefully considered and managed.
As such, we will need to work closely with industry (as we have done in the past) to get the best outcome.
By pursuing Solvency II and our statutory objectives, we will make our contribution to the sustainability of the insurance industry.
That importance of financial services to growth should be one of the big lessons of the Great Financial Crisis for anyone who did not appreciate the fact previously.
There are two aspects to this: we recognise that life insurers can be an important source of long-term, stable financing for corporates, infrastructure and mortgages - this is an important function that we want to see maintained; but we also must consider the wider financial stability angles, avoiding undue influence on the asset allocation behaviour of insurers.