Minouche Shafik
Bank of England
Track record: No forecast checked yet (18 not due, 10 being checked).
28forecasts & commitments on the record
68%can be checked as stated
46average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: based on data 24, stated on authority 2, educated guess 2.
Kinds of claim: forecast 20, mixed claim 5, scenario (if… then) 3. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence22 · 79%πρόνοιαPreparing for the future3 · 11%μαντείαInspired knowledge2 · 7%πρόβλεψιςSeeing the signs1 · 4%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (28)
For example, it is a lot easier to tweet 'BoE forecasts growth of 2%' than it is to tweet 'If economic circumstances identical to today were to prevail on 100 occasions, the best collective judgment of the MPC is that the mature estimate of GDP growth would lie above 2% on 50 occasions and below 2% on 50 occasions,' even …
It finds that even when domestic credit growth is moderate, elevated credit growth abroad could result in financial instability at home for example by boosting cross-border lending, through spillovers into domestic asset prices or by creating the potential for contagion in the event of a banking crisis abroad. 5
8 The 2016 stress test scenario, results of which will be published in 2016Q4, embodies a synchronised severe downturn in global output, which sees global growth trough at -1.9% as it did in 2008.
The full text of the code, including additional sections on governance, risk management and compliance, is on track for publication in May 2017.
Internationally, the Financial Stability Board is taking action to improve the alignment between remuneration and conduct risk 12 and (during 2017) will consult on:
Note: For the Bank of Engisrd's Galance sheet. projections are consistent with £606n of git asst purchaese over 2 quarters; comporsie bord purchases of £1060 aver 13 months commencing in September, and TFS usage of £100bn aver 16 months
The initial signs are good - standard variable rates have already been or, we expect, shortly will be reduced on the vast majority of existing mortgages, and the rates available on new lifetime tracker mortgages are on average 25bps lower. 4, 5 Though it is of course difficult to say how much of this is directly attributable to the TFS.
It will bring the stock of government bonds on our balance sheet up to £435bn, representing 23% of nominal GDP, a new high.
For example, Bank staff have revised up their forecast for the mature estimate of GDP growth in Q3 to 0.3% from 0.1% at the time of the August Inflation Report.
UK data show the percentage change between end-November 2013 and end-May 2016 (the latest data avaliable) in outstanding gill repo and reverse repo transactions of a 'sample of UK resident banks.
Our aim is that by the end of 2016 we will have agreed a blueprint for high-value sterling settlement in the years ahead, with technological development of that blueprint beginning in 2017.
If this is an important factor, the lags between headline inflation and the determination of pay awards mean it could increase the persistence of weak wage growth for some time to come.
For example, at the time we were producing the November Inflation Report, the market yield curve implied the first increase in Bank Rate would come in March 2017, and that it would reach 1¼% by the end of 2018.
That means that the 18% appreciation of sterling which began in early 2013 (as the prospects for the UK economy improved relative to those of our trading partners) is currently exerting significant downward pressure on inflation and is likely to continue to exert some downward pressure for several years to come as lower import costs pass through the supply chain.
The biggest domestic driver of inflation is labour costs per unit of output, and in order to generate inflation at target in the medium term, wages would ordinarily need to grow about 2 to 3 percentage points more quickly than productivity growth.
Recognising the financial stability risks that could emanate from a commitment to maintain low interest rates, the MPC set a 'knockout' whereby their guidance would cease to hold if the Financial Policy Committee judged that the stance of monetary policy poses a significant threat to financial stability that could not be contained by the combination of macro and micro prudential …
Motivated by concerns over the growth of household indebtedness, the FPC recommended that no more than 15% of mortgages originated could have a loan-to-income ratio above 4.5.
The IMF element is fragile, with borrowed resources accounting for an unprecedented three-quarters, around $500 billion of which are temporary loans due to start rolling off next year with no agreement in place to extend them [Chart 2].
Were the recovery in wage growth not to materialise and inflation to linger far below the 2% target for longer than currently embodied in the MPC's forecast, it would be a very undesirable outcome.
There has been a 44% decline in the price of oil from its peak, and a 17% appreciation of sterling since early 2013, and such phenomena can be expected to have large - but not permanent - effects on prices of consumer goods.
If that is true, then it suggests that Bank Rate is expected to average 2½% over the next 20 years (about half of its pre-crisis average of 5%).
Moreover, I think it is reasonable to expect that resumption in productivity growth to come over the next year or so as the continued narrowing of slack in the labour market raises the incentive to increase output by increasing output per worker .
Chart 10: Central banks will purchase around $125bn per month (on average)until September 2016.
Between the ECB and the Bank of Japan (which is continuing its programme of Qualitative and Quantitative Easing announced in early 2013), central banks will purchase the equivalent of around $125bn worth of assets per month between now and September 2016 (Chart 10).
In the wake of the financial crisis and ensuing recession, however, Bank Rate was cut to a historic low of 0.5% - a level that was at the time considered to be the effective lower bound as further cuts could reduce the profitability of the banking sector and constrain the supply of credit to the economy.
- The Bank will commence work in the second half of 2015 to assess the feasibility of establishing a Shari'ah compliant facility.
Some day we will also need to exit QE (though that will not come at least until Bank Rate has reached a level from which it could be materially cut were more stimulus required).
But we don't have a crystal ball, and should circumstances turn out differently, the MPC has the means, the will and the responsibility to return inflation to 2%.
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
A well-known example of such technocracy in action in the UK is the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) which is tasked with making the difficult trade-offs around which treatments will be funded by the National Health Service.
Research suggested that political pressure led to an 'inflation bias' in policymaking, which could be solved by delegating responsibility for price stability to independent central banks. 8 The following decades
As Andre Gide said, 'Trust those who seek the truth but doubt those who say they have found it.' 26 A good example of that is the use of 'fan charts' in forecasts produced by the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) which show the wide range of possible outcomes for a given set of initial circumstances. 27
Several others then feel obliged to chip in with other helpful innovations from the Romans, until finally Reg has to restate his question as 'Apart from the sanitation, the medicine, education, wine, public order, irrigation, roads, a fresh water system and public health, what have the Romans ever done for us?!'
Loose funds may sweep around the world, disorganising all steady business.' 1 And for him the prescription was clear: 'the movement of capital funds must be regulated; - which in itself will involve far-reaching departures from laissez-faire arrangements.' So must we return to a world of capital controls in order to break the cycle of boom and bust?
This is very similar to the estimated impact of domestic credit growth, suggesting that foreign credit growth could even be as important as domestic credit growth in explaining movements in each country's risk of a banking crisis.
There is mounting evidence that the effectiveness of macroprudential policies may be affected by leakages across borders.
For example, Cerutti et al (2015) and Reinhardt and Sowerbutts (2015) provide evidence that cross-border borrowing may increase after domestic macroprudential policy is tightened.
- In addition, the Prudential Regulation Authority has made clear that it expects firms to use a balance of both financial and non-financial factors (such as conduct metrics) when determining pay rewards and that financial metrics should be appropriately risk adjusted.
The nature of conduct risks will of course evolve over time and the official sector needs to stay on the front foot.
3 See European Central Bank Financial Stability Review May 2016.
Bank for International Settlements - the Foreign Exchange Working Group (2016), ' The FX Global Code: May 2016 Update' , https://www.bis.org/mktc/fxwg/gc\_may16.pdf