Jon Cunliffe
Independent Water Commission
Track record: No forecast checked yet (61 not due, 46 being checked).
107forecasts & commitments on the record
66%can be checked as stated
43average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: based on data 68, stated on authority 21, educated guess 18.
Kinds of claim: forecast 63, mixed claim 22, scenario (if… then) 18, commitment 4. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence61 · 57%μαντείαInspired knowledge19 · 18%πρόνοιαPreparing for the future18 · 17%προαναγγελίαPublic pre-announcement4 · 4%εἰκασίαConjecture4 · 4%πρόβλεψιςSeeing the signs1 · 1%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (107)
The Water Framework Directive sets a target to be achieved by 2027 - at a minimum - and the review will need to consider what targets should be set for after that date.
As we approach its target date, Government will, at a minimum, need to consider whether a new, post-2027 target should be set and what it should encompass.
A key priority on regulation in the nearterm will be for the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), in the first half of next year, to update their recommendation (which was originally developed 20 years ago) on detecting and preventing misuse of wire transfers by terrorists and other criminals.
CPMI is working on a report to the G20 next year on these governance and oversight issues that could serve as a useful reference for payment system owners and overseers, and it published an interim report for comment last week.
Earlier this year we issued a response to that consultation setting out that we will prioritise features supporting innovation and global initiatives, which include synchronised settlement, extended operating hours and non-payment APIs.
We and the FCA plan to consult later this year on the regulatory frameworks we will apply to stablecoins.
We intend early next year to consult in detail the regulatory framework that will apply to such systemic payment systems and the services, like wallets, that accompany them.
The FSB will publish a consultation report later this year with recommendations for promoting international consistency in regulatory and supervisory approaches to non-stablecoin cryptoassets, markets and exchanges as well as for strengthening international coordination in this area.
29 The Bank's Agents report that higher inflation will put upwards pressure on wage growth this year but that this will not persist beyond then.
It will feed through into consumer prices in October of this year. 17
The rate of inflation was forecast to begin to fall back later this year and next as the increase in energy prices dropped out of the annual inflation rate and the disinflationary impact of the drop in demand took hold.
As a consequence of this hit to demand, growth in economic activity was forecast to fall back materially, in the second half of this year.
The resulting squeeze on household incomes later this year and into next year was forecast at around a 2% reduction in disposable income.
At the same time the labour market was forecast to remain tight in the near term with unemployment continuing to fall until the middle of this year and pay continuing to grow above 4% annually until the autumn, before the effect of the income squeeze on activity and employment kicked in to offset the pressure in the labour market.
Even if prices rise in newly popular locations and the volume of mortgage transactions increased, there could be offsetting effects.
Building on the FCA's rules, the FPC has also recommended that lenders assess whether borrowers could meet their mortgage payments if their mortgage interest rate switched to the contractual reversion rate and increased by 3 percentage points.
and which will be tapered out over the course of this year - has fuelled the strength in demand for housing.
The pandemic that struck last spring was, and remains a true economic tail event; global GDP in the second quarter dropped by around 9% 1 and is not forecast by the IMF to return to pre COVID levels until at least 2022 2 .
A 3.8 percentage point capital drawdown (the drawdown we expect banks to face in the MPC's illustrative scenario) would have depleted a very significant fraction of the capital banks had available.
And they have pre-positioned assets at the Bank of England against which they could draw down around £380bn of liquidity. 4
In the UK, the desktop stress test carried out by the Financial Policy Committee on the basis of the scenario for the economy in the MPC's May Monetary policy Report 3 , indicates the banks could face up to £80bn of credit losses over the next two years.
Given Facebook's pre-existing network of around 2.5bn users, Libra if introduced could very quickly become systemically important. 14
And given the potential and likely use of stablecoins in cross border payments, we are considering these risks internationally within the Financial Stability Board, which will report this year on developing regulatory recommendations with respect to stablecoins.
And this year, we will consult on giving greater access to our balance sheet as well as our infrastructure to non-bank payment providers.
3 In addition to affecting the market rates directly, monetary policy easing could lead to a further compression in market rates because of spill-overs via exchange rates (in case of interest rate cuts) or compression of term premia (in case of asset purchases).
If though, house price growth outpaces income growth in the future then the policies will have a greater impact.
If house prices and incomes grow broadly at the same rate then the distribution of indebtedness in the flow of new mortgages will not change much - and hence the impact of policies on the flow will not be large.
And by providing some check, in aggregate, on excessive credit growth relative to income, these tools could also provide benefits in the event of debt-financed overconsumption, if it were driven by highly indebted households or looser underwriting standards.
By constraining the increase in the aggregate number of highly indebted households, the tools reduce the proportion of households that could have insufficient liquid assets or lose access to credit in the event of a shock.
But we will continue to see a change in the distribution of the stock of mortgages for some time yet as newer, higher LTI mortgages gradually replace older, lower LTI mortgages.
This test had recently been implemented in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority as a consumer protection measure. 7 But the FPC recommended that the calibration of the test should take account of macro-prudential risks; we recommended that lenders assess whether borrowers could still afford their mortgages if interest rates were to increase by 3 percentage points. 8
One could ask a similar question about the very aggressive growth in leveraged lending to corporates in the US, which in 2017 spread to the UK. 29 The stock of UK leveraged loans is estimated to have grown by about a third in the year to 2018 thanks to gross loan issuance in that period which was nearly 70% larger …
It could accelerate if and when Brexit uncertainty is resolved in which case aggregate credit could begin to grow quickly and the FPC would need to consider how to respond.
But the latest readings do not signal strongly that pay growth will make the next step to establish itself firmly in 3% territory in line with the May forecast. 12 We may still be underestimating supply in the labour market. 13
GDP in the three months to May - the ONS's first of its new monthly GDP releases - grew at 0.2%, with services growing at 0.4%, indicating a recovery over April.
2 Mark Carney's recent speech illustrates that bank rate might have risen by 2-3 percentage points between August 2013 and the end of 2014 if the post crisis MPC's had followed the reaction function of its pre-crisis predecessors.
And, crucially, that the domestic economy is likely to generate the relatively gentle inflation pressure necessary to meet the target over the next two years, as the current external inflationary pressures from sterling's depreciation wane.
The higher frequency measure of pay growth, 3 month on 3 month growth, has been above 2.5% for 11 months between last May and March this year - the longest run of such consistent wage growth since the crisis ( Chart 7 ).
In May the MPC forecast that CPI would be at 2.2% by the year end.
If counterparties have confidence that resolution will stabilise a bank so that it can continue to meet its obligations, they will not accelerate actions that could frustrate a resolution to the detriment of all parties.
This penny seems to have dropped with investors in the larger banks - the implicit public subsidy that the large 'too big to fail' banks enjoyed in the price of their debt has been eroded and rating agencies no longer assume that UK banks will get public support if they get into trouble. 8
Surveys suggest the majority of customers are relatively satisfied with their banking services. 16 Around 2 million UK bank customers already use rudimentary services of this kind - PSD2 and Open Banking will enable greater security and functionality.
Indeed, over the last few years, demand for cash if anything has gone up slightly growing from about £70bn at the end of 2014 to over £80bn at end 2017. 11 Some of this demand can probably be attributed to the use of cash as a store of value - 'money under the mattress' and to the reduced cost of …
One reason for this might be the stability of inflation expectations around the Bank of England's 2% target.
Inflation is currently above target as a result of the post referendum depreciation of sterling and forecast, for that reason, to remain so over the next three years.
If workers are surprised on the upside by inflation they will build that higher expected inflation into their bid for the next year and vice versa.
Indeed, in its review of the supply side of the economy in February of this year, the MPC appealed to evidence that secular improvements in the educational attainment of the workforce are likely to have improved the efficiency of the labour market and lowered trend unemployment and, as a result lowered the natural rate assumed in our forecast (Chart 7).
The forecast is based on the increase in Bank rate to 0.5% which the Committee agreed at its last meeting and on the market path for interest rates, which implies Bank rate rising to 1% over the next three years.
The MPC's November Inflation Report forecast, which is the best collective judgement of the Committee, is that inflation will peak around 3% this year.
In the UK, the Independent Commission on Banking suggested a capital surcharge of 3% of risk-weighted assets (RWA) for banks that could not be resolved.
Showing the newest 50 - the ledger has all 107.
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
But second, and more importantly, if we are to achieve the water sector we need, we need to look at all the factors that have contributed to our ‘Great Stink’ moment and recognise that those factors, if not addressed, will hamper us going forward.
We also make several important recommendations as to how the price review process - which should be retained alongside and informed by supervisory engagement - might be simplified and reformed.
We have to recognise that the cost of producing water and wastewater services is likely to increase over the medium and longer term as the industry has to replace ageing assets, respond to higher environmental and public health standards and continue to adapt to the challenges of rising population growth and climate change.
The Commission’s report is long and detailed with multiple recommendations because – as I have said – there is no one, single reform, no matter how radical, that will deliver what is needed: we need to act on all of the failures that have brought us to the present pass.
But, as with the ‘Great Stink’ in 1858, without such direction from the very top, we will not achieve the change we need.
And to be clear, this is not just about the setting of objectives – indeed the setting of objectives is the easier task compared to the much thornier job of providing guidance on how objectives that may not align should be reconciled.
Given that the risk profiles of companies generally is going to change as the investment in new infrastructure increases and becomes an increasing proportion of their business, this is an important area on which we need to look forward as well as learn from past experience.
And while there can never be absolute certainty and standards and societies expectations will change, investors, in water company equity and debt, need to be able to trust that the regulatory system through time will be generally stable and predictable.
Nor should you infer – or try to infer – from the Call what the Commission’s recommendations will be.
We are, bluntly, not at the recommendations stage and we will not be there for some months.
While the data are not perfect and there are important gaps we need to address, we are now able not only to measure how far we have to go but also to identify more precisely the areas for action that are likely to yield the greatest improvement.
There are a number of issues concerning the issuance and transfer of bank deposits in tokenised form that will need to be considered by bank regulators and banks themselves, including whether such tokens should be permitted to circulate freely like digital banknotes. But the underlying nature of the claim, deposit protection and management of risks should be regulated in the …