John Gieve
Bank of England
Track record: No forecast checked yet (36 not due, 10 being checked).
46forecasts & commitments on the record
83%can be checked as stated
48average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: based on data 30, stated on authority 9, educated guess 7.
Kinds of claim: forecast 32, scenario (if… then) 6, mixed claim 5, commitment 3. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence29 · 63%πρόνοιαPreparing for the future6 · 13%μαντείαInspired knowledge6 · 13%προαναγγελίαPublic pre-announcement3 · 7%εἰκασίαConjecture2 · 4%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (46)
If they feel that we are not accepting responsibility for what happens to growth and jobs, they will look for someone else to do so.
But to pretend that all this could have been avoided had interest rates been 25 basis points higher over the last couple of years seems to me pure wishful thinking.
Coupled with the deflationary impact of falling commodity prices and the cut in VAT, CPI inflation will continue falling over the year and may go well below the target rate of 2% despite the impact of sterling's depreciation on import prices.
So there is a limited amount we can do at this point to influence the path of output in the first half of this year (although there may be ways of mitigating the costs).
The Bank of Spain estimates the current level of general provisions could absorb losses associated with a doubtful assets ratio of 9% (the current level is 1.5%).
The more we raise the cost of cost of increasing lending by banks, the greater the incentive we will create for the growth of intermediation outside the regulated banking sector or to foreign banks not subject to such counter-cyclical requirements.
However, if we do not tackle this we will see the growth of national restrictions on the terms on which cross-border operations are permitted - in terms of capital, liquidity and legal structure - and that could have great economic costs.
In the July 2006 FSR, for example the Bank warned of 'UK banks' increasing dependence on wholesale funding' and, in April 2007, we noted that: 'if UK banks were unable to securitise existing assets, new lending would need to be financed through other wholesale sources, which may be difficult or costly to access during times of stress.' So it proved.
In my view it has been particularly important through recent months, when each forecast has been higher than the one before and each inflation figure has exceeded the earlier forecast, not to confuse the central message that we will set policy to bring inflation back down to target.
Since those projections were put together, oil prices have risen a further 20% and food prices by a further 5%.
If the sharp credit squeeze was the only challenge we faced, the Monetary Policy Committee would be expected to continue reducing rates to mitigate the risks of an excessive fall in demand and in inflation in the medium term.
The peak monthly rate will depend on the exact timing of energy price rises but we are expecting inflation to be well over 4% for much of the rest of the year.
We are a little behind the US where inflation now stands at 5% or the Euro area where it has reached 4% but the gap is expected to continue to narrow.
In the May Inflation Report , the Committee forecast a pickup in inflation to well over 3 per cent, above target and driven in large part by the huge rises we have seen in energy and food prices (Chart 3).
As the Governor explained in his open letter to the Chancellor, when the rise in energy prices passes through to consumers, CPI inflation is likely to rise sharply in the second half of the year, to above 4%.
Taken together energy and food components can account for 1.1 percentage points of the 1.2 percentage points increase in CPI inflation from 2.1% in December last year to 3.3% in May.
The share of Chinese goods in total UK goods imports has almost tripled in money terms over the past fifteen years to around 8 per cent, and it's likely that much of the content of imports from elsewhere originated in China.
Ladies and Gentlemen, it is a great pleasure to be here this evening in what has been a busy week for the Bank, with the open letter to the Chancellor in response to the news on Tuesday that CPI inflation rose to 3.3% in May, the latest MPC minutes, and the Chancellor's announcement last night of an enhanced role for …
The next year is not going to be comfortable for anyone and we already hear calls to change the system, the target, and our focus on inflation.
And the Committee's commitment to ensuring inflation returns to the 2% target should give those setting prices and wages some confidence that inflation will be close to target in the future.
Even in five years time - and on some of the fastest growth projections - assets under management by sovereign wealth funds are projected to reach only about 6% of global financial assets. 6 Moreover, though they have more assets under management than hedge funds they have smaller investments since they are not leveraged. 7
What I have in mind is a government investment vehicle that manages foreign assets with a higher risk tolerance and higher expected returns than for central bank foreign currency reserves. 1 The size of such funds is hard to measure, but may be in the $2-3 trillion range.
If investors are no longer willing to finance the deficit, domestic spending will need to be cut relative to output through a combination of reducing spending and switching production to the tradable sector.
2 Arguably the cash flow projection of losses of $150 billion comes closest to the sort of provisions banks would be making if the loans had been held on their banking books rather than securitised and sold on.
On that basis the losses currently projected would be only 50% of the Savings and Loans losses as a share of US GDP.
Second, if projecting forward the rate at which delinquencies are cumulating on recent vintages of subprime mortgages, we can estimate that losses on the securitised loans might ultimately exceed $150 billion.
So long as there are known to be reluctant holders, even long term real money investors will tend to hold back to see whether prices are driven lower in coming months by forced sales.
Declines in commercial property prices will weaken corporate balance sheets and this could affect corporate spending if lenders raise the cost of borrowing to affected companies.
Weakening property prices would reduce the amount that lenders could realise in the event of default.
It has been estimated that the effect of the tightening of credit conditions was to reduce UK output in 1991 by almost 2% relative to what it would otherwise have been. 4 Of course, there was little monetary policy could do at that time to offset these effects because of Sterling's ERM membership.
These are likely to raise our inflation rate well above target in the coming months at a time when short term inflation expectations remain uncomfortably high.
The Deloitte CFO survey taken in early December finds that 20% of firms expect the recent credit market events to have a negative impact on their capital spending in 2008. 7
At that point there were only two out of 47 who expected interest rates to rise above 5% by now and only one expected them to be below 4.25%.
The story of the last year has been that growth has been stable (between 0.7 and 0.8% each quarter) and kept quite close to that central projection but only on the basis of substantially higher interest rates than our forecasts were based on; inflation has been higher than we projected again despite the successive rises in rates.
If you go back a year to May 2006, our central projections for Q2 2007 were for growth of about 3% and inflation of around 2%.
We have also been benefiting from benign world conditions with the emergence of low cost producers in the Far East and strong world GDP growth, which has been over 5 % in the last 3 years, the strongest 3-year period of growth since 1968-70, and there is every reason to hope that this benign trend will continue.
In my view it is sensible for independent forecasters to assume that we will do our job and keep inflation low; but we can't take comfort from the fact that most external forecasters therefore expect inflation to return and stay around target - its our job to justify their faith and keep their confidence.
Fast forward to the most recent survey and you will see that none of the 52 expect rates to go above 6% in the next year and only two expect rates to go below 5.5%.
The jobs figures understate the importance of the sector in the economy because on average pay may be twice as high in the financial sector as in the rest of the economy; 9% of wages and salaries in the year to March compared to 4% of employment.
More immediately, the GDP figures in May showed that financial intermediation grew by 6% in the sixth months to 2007 Q1 - an annual rate of over 13%.
In 2008 the ONS plan to expand the GDP figures to include what is called FISIM and reflects those activities of banks which they cover by their net interest income. 6 That will improve estimates of GDP, but they will continue to exclude income that banks earn through proprietary dealing.
Readers of the Bank's Financial Stability Report (next edition due next month) - or those that have read the financial news - will know that the financial markets have been buoyant recently; in particular the premia for risks in the credit market are very low and profit growth and bonuses have been spectacular.
Given the funds already raised by private equity firms, this might be expected to increase further in 2007.
We saw the same phenomenon on a much smaller scale in May and June this year.
If wage and price setters believed that inflation was going to rise above the target, then they would make some allowance for this in setting
My view therefore is that the disinflationary pressure from globalisation may well have been more substantial than the direct estimates suggest, and this helps to explain why inflation has fallen throughout the world over the last 15 years from 30% in the early 1990s to about 4% in 2003. 6 This
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
And it could also require a global fiscal authority with deep pockets to whom the regulator could turn should one of these institutions fall into distress.
I hope we will agree two things to put to the G20 summit - a statement of principles on how countries should cooperate in planning for and handling crises in cross border institutions and a programme to put in place better arrangements for information sharing and cross border dialogue on the largest banks in the world.
Indeed it is by bringing output back to potential that we will bring inflation back to target.
We don't know how deep and prolonged this recession will be or how soon and completely financial markets will recover.
The severity and nature of the challenges we face particularly in the banking sector makes it very difficult to predict where we will be in a year from now.
One lesson of the last 18 months has been that in the medium term banks need to work with lower leverage and higher buffers of capital and liquidity.
In the United Kingdom, we expect the sharpest fall in output for decades while on some measures, retail prices are likely to fall for the first time in almost half a century.
The credit boom may not have led to a rapid inflation in the price of goods and services, but it did support a surge in the price of a broad range of assets.
Such funding could be treated as an added risk factor in assessing a bank's liquidity needs and those needs should be reflected in a requirement to hold high quality liquid assets.
No doubt we could do better in national policy making but we also need to recognise that the sum of policies which make sense at the national level may well not be optimal at the global level.
The extraordinary measures we have taken in this country and others are having a positive impact but we may need to do more.
While these will not all fall on banks and may exaggerate the losses to those who can hold debt to maturity, investors and counterparties became worried about the extent of the likely losses on banking and trading books in a wider range of institutions and in their ability to continue to finance their businesses.