Fernando Restoy
Bank of Spain
Track record: No forecast checked yet (15 not due, 17 being checked).
32forecasts & commitments on the record
47%can be checked as stated
48average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: based on data 24, stated on authority 4, educated guess 4.
Kinds of claim: forecast 21, mixed claim 6, scenario (if… then) 5. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence23 · 72%πρόνοιαPreparing for the future5 · 16%μαντείαInspired knowledge4 · 12%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (32)
Concerning the first point, the volume of MREL required to absorb the bank's losses might be adjusted downwards if it is taken into account that, generally, banks are declared to be in resolution when they fail to meet the regulatory requirements and, therefore, before depleting - due to losses - all the capital they hold.
Let us take a bank financed only with capital and deposits and that comfortably meets e.g. with a surplus of 2 pp - its regulatory capital requirement, which we will place in this example at 10% of its risk-weighted assets (RWAs).
The decisions on capital, the adoption of which for 2016 will be shortly formalised, will, for all the SSM's significant institutions, entail average capital requirements somewhat higher than those of the previous year: around 30 basis points (bp), rising to 50 bp if the impact of the phasing-in of the capital buffers envisaged in European legislation is taken into account.
The results will be published at the start of the third quarter of 2016.
This test, following the methodology of the European Banking Authority, will be made on a sample of banks - six of which Spanish - covering 70% of euro area banking assets.
I trust that this agreement, once it is finally approved by the ECB, may be implemented in the opening months of 2016 and that, in any event, future revisions of European legislation will envisage less room for discretion on the part of the Member States, so that the singleness of the relevant legal framework for banking activity throughout the EU …
Just a few weeks back we celebrated the first anniversary of the start-up of the first of the three pillars of the Banking Union project, the Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM); the Single Resolution Mechanism, the second pillar of the Banking Union, is now under way and will be fully operational from 1 January 2016.
As you will recall, in January this year a recommendation on dividend distribution policy was adopted in which banks were urged to keep conservative dividend distribution arrangements so as to preserve their solvency.
All told, the expectations that interest rates will stay low for some time make it advisable not only to remain vigilant to the evolution of these risks, but, as a precautionary measure, to reflect on the actions needed to mitigate them and minimise their impact if they do arise.
In the case of the euro area, interest rates fell by over 300 basis points to 1% in scarcely seven months from October 2008 to May 2009.
Given that the cost of capital could reach around 10% it is clear that profitability must improve, to allow banks to attract the funds that the growth in lending and the new regulatory requirements demand.
In particular, it is reasonable to assume that stricter prudential regulations will moderate banks' profits, if for no other reason than the higher regulatory cost they impose on high-risk exposures which are usually also those that generate higher expected returns.
The need for this involvement is heightened by the entry into force in 2018 of the new standard (IFRS 9) under which banks will switch from using the concept of incurred loss to that of expected loss in order to calculate the credit portfolio provision.
That said, regulatory changes and competitive pressure also pose an important challenge for these institutions which will require them to maintain sufficient levels of operational effectiveness, effective control of risk concentration and, especially, sound foundations for ensuring that regulatory capital is preserved and, if necessary, increased.
I trust this will all come to light in the assessment exercise which, as you know, is being conducted at the European level as part of the groundwork for the start-up of the Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM) in November this year.
We might also add here the acquisition by the DGF of shares valued at €1,803 million of Nova Caixa Galicia Banco Catalunya Banc held by minority investors in these banks following the burden-sharing exercises undertaken, and the subscription by the FROB of capital and subordinated debt instruments of Sareb for a total of €2,192 million.
Further, the convertible bonds subscribed by the FROB in Caja3 (absorbed by Ibercaja), CEISS (absorbed by Unicaja) and Liberbank, are highly likely to be redeemed before 2017, entailing the return of €1,135 million.
The information available indicates that year-on-year growth rates might draw close to 2% late next year.
In particular, it might be advisable, at least for the systemically important financial institutions, to add to the ex-post minimum global 8% bail-in threshold an ex-ante minimum amount of specific instruments that could be readily converted into equity immediately after the point of non-viability is achieved, e.g. through specific clauses in the subscription contracts of those instruments.
The implementation and quality control stages of the stress test will commence from next month, meaning there will be some overlap with the asset review exercise.
Remember that the portfolios selected for the review amount to 58% of the risk-weighted assets of the 128 institutions, i.e. some €3.72 trillion, which will involve reviewing in detail an average of 1,250 credit records per bank.
Under this process, the system of burden-sharing among the national and mutualised funds will be gradually adjusted until the national compartments disappear completely around January 2025.
Next year, banks will be required to publish the ratio as a transparency measure, which will be conducive to the final design of the new regulatory requirement attaining a sufficient degree of consistency and homogeneity.
1% to reflect the systemic importance of the significant institutions that will be overseen by the single supervisory mechanism.
In particular, significant banks - which account for 80% of the sector - will be directly overseen by the new European supervisory authority.
By the end of the year we expect capital levels to be above 10% for the sector as a whole, both under the EBA definition and under the Basel III definition of common equity tier 1 to be used from January when the new European solvency regulations come into force.
For an idea of the overall impact of these measures, it suffices to say that the minimum CET1 requirement of 2% under the previous legislation could be, on average, around 1% if the new requirements are applied.
This new framework has been incorporated, as you know, into European legislation through the Capital Requirements Directive and Regulation which will be implemented on 1 January 2014.
Fortunately, the latest data support expectations of a gradual recovery of the Spanish economy, which might have already begun in the third quarter of this year according to data published by the Banco de España last week.
Thus, banks, as a rule, will have to maintain a minimum level of top quality capital of 7% in terms of their risk-weighted assets.
The draft regulation foresees that the ECB will start performing its functions through national supervisors already in January next year and that the new system will be fully operational in 2014.
It is probably reasonable to expect that the overall supervisory framework should evolve over time beyond January 2014.
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
In light of the foregoing, even if the minimum volume of the loss-absorbing instruments that banks should have is revised downwards, the new MREL demands may undeniably only be assumed by a large number of banks if they have a sufficiently lengthy transition period to comply with the requirements.
All told, institutions should be mindful that the new resolution framework will require those banks that exceed a certain size and are liable to generate systemic risk to ensure that their balance sheet structure allows their resolution at the expense, essentially, of their shareholders and creditors.
This transition period will, moreover, be necessary so that the market should not have to absorb a large number of issues over a limited period of time.
Indeed, the Key Attributes specify the powers and tools the administrative authorities should have to see through the orderly resolution of non-viable banks, ensuring the maintenance of their core functions and their restructuring at the least possible cost to the taxpayer.
More importantly, significant institutions will have to hold on their balance sheets substantial volumes of liabilities that could be subject to bail-in.
I imagine that probably much of the agenda of your regular meetings is devoted to exchanging experiences on how financial institutions such as those participating in the European Savings and Retail Banking Group (ESBG) are addressing the current challenges affecting the entire financial sector in the current post-crisis period.
First, the low interest rate environment, which is putting heavy pressure on financial margins, particularly for institutions -such as most of those belonging to the ESBG - with little investment in securities that could be revalued as rates go down, and with much funding obtained from retail deposits, which impedes a full transmission of very low or negative market rates …
Clearly, those retail banks with little or no tradition in issuing capital and other securities in capital markets will have particular difficulties coping with the enhanced regulatory framework.
Admittedly, though, the corporate structure of many retail banks -particularly those which are not yet regular corporations listed in capital markets - may face less immediate pressure to restore higher profitability levels.
The latter are managed independently of the foundation and take the form of regular corporations which, in most cases, are or will soon be listed in capital markets.
In this connection, I shall first briefly review the situation of the banking sector, focusing thereafter on the challenges banks will have to face in the short and medium term.
In particular, under the Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive (BRRD), significant institutions shall, in addition to meeting the established capital requirements, have a minimum volume of liabilities enabling losses to be absorbed should it be necessary.