Edward M Gramlich
US Federal Reserve System
Track record: No forecast checked yet (32 not due, 2 being checked).
34forecasts & commitments on the record
88%can be checked as stated
54average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: educated guess 21, based on data 12, stated on authority 1.
Kinds of claim: scenario (if… then) 19, forecast 10, mixed claim 5. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόνοιαPreparing for the future19 · 56%πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence10 · 29%εἰκασίαConjecture4 · 12%μαντείαInspired knowledge1 · 3%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (34)
The first of these target agreements defined price stability as a range of 0 percent to 2 percent in New Zealand's Consumers Price Index (CPI), set a goal of achieving price stability two years hence, and gave conditions that could justify going outside the price stability band.
But because outlays greatly exceed revenues at the end of the projection period, the infinite-horizon unfunded liability is much larger, $11.1 trillion, or 1.2 percent of the discounted present value of GDP, which is tantamount to an immediate 3.5 percentage point increase in payroll tax rates.
On net, the changes recommended here might improve the overall balance of Social Security plus Part A of Medicare by about 3.5 percentage points of taxable wages and salaries.
By 1996 it was down to only 7.5 percent of workers in physically demanding jobs, and by the time any of my suggested measures take effect, the share should be on the order of 3 or 4 percent - not zero, but probably not high enough to argue against measures to raise the retirement age at a gradual rate.
The primary deficit averages around 2 percent of GDP for the next few years before gradually shrinking, and the debt-GDP ratio climbs back to about 45 percent by 2015.
If the demand growth that caused the oil price increases is domestic, it could mean that the price shock might be less permanent.
Second, as before, if prices were highly sensitive to supply shocks but not sensitive to output movements, even nominal income targeting could imply substantial increases in unemployment.
If prices were at all sluggish in their response to changes in unemployment, this approach could entail large increases in unemployment from the shock.
Of course, such a substitution will not necessarily lower aggregate demand if it requires more investment demand for new energy-saving equipment.
Even if the oil producers are domestic, a drop in domestic demand could still occur if the producers do not spend as much of their new income as consumers would have or if they do not recycle their profits to shareholders.
The process worked as follows: if projected deficits in the next fiscal year exceeded the targets by $10 billion or more, the legislation mandated that unprotected programs be cut, across-the-board, and by enough to reach the legislated targets.
We have seen problems in the past with periods that were too short - for example, under GRH, the annual budget targets could be met by simply pushing costs into the next year.
In contrast, if we allow debt to build now and in coming years, we will have both lower output to meet future obligations as well as the added burden of financing a growing amount of debt.
If the effective interest rate on debt is slightly below the growth rate, as it has generally been found to be in the past for both deficits, a nation with outstanding debt could run slight primary deficits and not see the debt ratio grow. 4
If it is, interest payments on the debt will, in equilibrium, also settle down to a stable proportion of GDP.
For example, if there were to be an investment boom, interest rates might rise to induce some new private saving and some new lending by foreigners.
And even at that level, the stability condition is violated by at least 1 percent of GDP, suggesting that the debt-to-GDP ratio is likely to climb steadily upward. 7
It will take extraordinary fiscal discipline just to keep the present primary deficit near its current level of 1 to 2 percent of GDP over the short, medium, and long run.
If they are violated, the natural adjustment mechanisms will eventually take over for the trade deficit, and the primary budget deficit will eventually have to be reduced to stop a growing government debt ratio.
Macro-model simulations indicate that if the central bank exercises only traditional policy instruments, the zero-bound problem could significantly increase the severity of recessions.
Regarding the zero bound, as inflation drops toward zero, nominal interest rates drop toward real rates, which themselves might be low if the reason inflation is dropping involves negative demand shocks.
The upshot of this highly anecdotal test is that I have long suspected that true price stability might really be achieved in the vicinity of measured inflation rates of 2 percent or even more.
In these circumstances, with prices actually falling, the central bank may have little choice but to expand liquidity quite rapidly in the hope that the liquidity will arrest deflation, even if nominal short rates remain stuck in the neighborhood of zero for a range of monetary growth rates.
Thus, if payroll taxes were to be cut, the fiscal flows would have to be kept separate from the social security system.
But as with income taxes, if rates are cut only for a short time, the funds will appear to be temporary to consumers, in which case their effect on consumption may not be very large.
On the other hand, if consumers are not forward-looking but wait for their tax cuts before they begin spending, the accelerated rate cuts could stimulate a normal amount of consumer spending.
If future tax-rate cuts are already enacted into law, putting them into effect sooner than planned could be done quickly.
At this point, and according to the Blue Chip forecasters, the recession seems to have been much milder than most, with the unemployment rate unlikely to go much above 6 percent.
If they would like to consume more but cannot because unsecured borrowing is difficult, then at least modest increases in house prices should not reduce their consumption.
However, these households would still have no resources to increase their consumption of other goods, unless they could sell their houses or borrow against their housing equity.
They would clearly do this if deflation threatened, but they might do it even with low positive rates of inflation below target ranges.
Or, if inflation fell below target ranges, some central banks might take steps to boost inflation by expansionary monetary policy.
In such circumstances, a cautious central bank might well just wait for signs of inflation to emerge, thwart the inflation if it occurs, and not rely as heavily on normal measures of aggregate demand growth or labor market tightness.
On the unemploy side, the fear that inflation will accelerate if unemployment drops below an estimated natu at this point proven groundless - inflation has not accelerated when unemployment has rema a zone that would have been felt to be well below the estimated natural rate.
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
Your ability to demystify the mortgage market and identify trends greatly improves the public's understanding of the housing market - the market for one of the most important financial transactions an individual will ever undertake.
Generally, for-profit lenders that have offices in metropolitan areas and that have more than $34 million in assets, or whose mortgage lending represents 10 percent of their lending originations, must report under HMDA.
Simultaneously, the Federal Reserve, together with the other agencies that make up the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council and the Department of Housing and Urban Development, has been explaining to financial institutions and to the public the uses and limitations of the pricing data and how these data will be used by bank examiners.
HMDA data have been used to identify credit demand that might otherwise have been overlooked.
Instead, the data will be used as a screen to identify any aspects of the higher-priced end of the mortgage market that warrant closer scrutiny.
It is always possible that banks could disclose additional information on their own, but even this is questionable from a legal standpoint.
The Fed might not have to coordinate with both houses of the Congress, but it would certainly have to coordinate with both parties.
Remarks by Mr Edward M Gramlich, Member of the Board of Governors of the US Federal Reserve System, at the Euromoney Inflation Conference, Paris, 26 May 2005.
These advantages are offset by the fact that inflation targeting could lead to rigid or formulaic policies that limit flexibility.
The general verdict of the many comparison studies seems to be in favor of inflation targeting, but something else, most likely the sheer commitment to price stability, has also appeared to have worked just as well in the United States.
There may also be a correlation between governmental involvement and the strictness of the inflation-targeting regime.
Disaster is not imminent, but it seems pretty clear that in the not too distant future the United States, too, will have to confront some distinctly unpleasant policy choices.