Edward George
Bank of England
Track record: No forecast checked yet (48 not due, 49 being checked).
97forecasts & commitments on the record
70%can be checked as stated
50average ambiguity (0-100)
0goalpost moves recorded
0confirmed U-turns
Timeline
came true partly did not not due / being checked / too vague
Calibration score: shown after 10 checked forecasts with a stated likelihood (now 0).
How they speak about the future: based on data 36, educated guess 34, stated on authority 27.
Kinds of claim: forecast 53, scenario (if… then) 22, mixed claim 19, commitment 3. · Download this report card as a picture
In the nine words
πρόγνωσιςInference from evidence35 · 36%μαντείαInspired knowledge21 · 22%πρόνοιαPreparing for the future21 · 22%εἰκασίαConjecture12 · 12%πρόβλεψιςSeeing the signs3 · 3%προαναγγελίαPublic pre-announcement3 · 3%φρόνησιςPractical wisdom2 · 2%
How to read this
Each box is one sentence a public figure or institution said about the future, word for word, with a link to the official text. Can be checked means it names what will happen, by when, and how likely - so it can be compared with official figures later. Too vague to check means it does not. Ambiguity (0-100) is how many different ways the sentence can be read. When the date passes, the forecast is compared with official data and marked came true, partly or did not come true. Labels judge the sentence, never the person. Full guide and glossary.On the record (97)
thinking that the external environment will now gradually improve as we move through the second half of this year into next, and that this will help to offset the gradual moderation we are beginning to see in the growth of consumer spending.
On that basis we would also expect to see a gradual recovery in domestic business investment as we go through this year and into next.
for example in the labour market, so that inflation seems likely to fall back to the 2½% target rate in the course of next year.
Notwithstanding these risks, I still think that the most likely outcome is that we will see a gradual pickup in the pace of global recovery over the next year or two - which is the view shared by the Monetary Policy Committee in our February Inflation Report and by most other economic commentators.
They discount the relatively low debt-service to income ratio on the grounds that it could rise sharply if interest rates went up, and ask what might happen if unemployment were to start to rise sharply.
At the time of our last Inflation Report published in November the MPC's collective view of the most likely outcome for the UK, looking over the next two years, was for growth at around trend with inflation close to target.
So it is not all obvious to me at least that the household sector will suddenly run for cover in the current environment, where the labour market remains remarkably robust, and the prospect for inflation - and hence the prospect for interest rates - remains relatively benign, remaining somewhat above target in the near term but moving down gradually as …
But, looking beyond that, the US economy is underpinned by its robust financial system, by continuing rapid underlying productivity growth, and by strongly supportive monetary and fiscal policies, so that most forecasters anticipate US growth of 2 ½ - 3% this year and somewhat more next.
All in all, we - along with many other macro-economic forecasters - expect that after somewhat slower growth in the 4th quarter - US GDP will continue to expand at an annual rate of 3-3‰% over the next two years.
We recognised that this was not without risks -risks in terms of the build-up of household debt and of an unsustainable rate of increase in house prices, if not an actual bubble -which, if persisted in for too long, or if carried too far, could lead to an uncomfortable retrenchment further ahead.
Some people have suggested that we might have done more to weaken the exchange rate -particularly against the generally weak euro -by cutting our interest rates more aggressively, but it really isn't as simple as that: exchange rates don't respond predictably to relative interest rates -certainly in the short term; if anything in recent conditions cutting them further could even …
By the early summer both the MPC and financial markets were contemplating the possibility that we might soon need to act to moderate the growth of domestic demand, if that did not happen of its own accord, in order to accommodate a pick up in external demand.
I wish I could claim that life will get easier looking forward to 2020 - but I can't promise that and you wouldn't believe me anyway!
The necessary moderation of consumer demand growth could come about of its own accord, if, for example, consumers become more reluctant to take on additional debt.
The consensus economic forecast is for overall growth in the US - perhaps after something of a lull in the second quarter - to pick up steadily to around trend - to 3% or perhaps somewhat more - through the second half of the year into next.
And inflation, though rather more volatile from month to month, averaged 2.2% over the past year very close to our 2½% target, although it fell to 1.8% in May.
What is clear is that if external demand does improve as we expect, and if consumer demand growth does not moderate to accommodate it, then we will need at some point to raise interest rates to bring that moderation about.
That will in due course mean that domestic demand growth - and consumer demand growth in particular - will need to moderate if we are to avoid a build up of inflationary pressure.
And that, Subhash, is of course my answer to your second question - "what precisely will happen to interest rates?" In case any of you are confused, I think that what I said was that interest rates will rise - unless they fall or stay the same!
There have recently been encouraging, but still tentative, signs that the worst of the global slowdown may now be behind us, and that the US and Eurozone economies are now beginning to bottom out and will pick up, perhaps to around trend, as we go through this year.
I am "cautiously optimistic" that the overseas environment will improve as we move through 2002, and that by this time next year we here in the UK will have seen a return to somewhat stronger and better balanced growth, with unemployment not far above its recent lows, and with continuing low inflation.
That will in due course mean that domestic demand growth - and consumer demand growth in particular - will need to moderate if we are to avoid a build up of inflationary pressure.
This last concern will be on the agenda of the Monterrey conference next month.
There have recently been encouraging, but tentative, signs that the worst of the global slowdown may now be behind us, and that the US and Eurozone economies are now beginning to bottom out and are likely to pick up as we go through this year, perhaps to around trend.
I am "cautiously optimistic" that the overseas environment will improve as we move through the year, and that by this time next year we here in the UK will have seen a return to somewhat stronger and better balanced growth, with unemployment not far above its recent lows, and with continuing low inflation.
But I can assure you that if, as we move forward, it seems likely that the overall economy will be weaker than we currently expect, and inflation lower, then we are prepared to reduce interest rates further, just as we stand ready to raise them if the overall economy, and inflation, appear likely to be stronger than we currently anticipate.
In the context of globalisation, that was reflected in the Doha agreement on a new round of world trade negotiations; and development financing will be the theme of the Monterrey Summit next month.
There is no doubt that if we could simply redraw the map, we would opt for stronger external demand and weaker consumption growth.
On the one side, we may find it increasingly difficult to offset the negative impact of the global slowdown in the face of increasing domestic private sector debt; and if the slowdown in the UK spreads beyond manufacturing to the services sectors it may cause unemployment to rise which in turn could slow the growth of consumer spending.
On that view one could envisage a gradual adjustment over time in which case the US might face a protracted period of nearstagnation; or - if you were really pessimistic - the adjustments might be more abrupt, implying a period of negative growth and possible further financial instability.
You might suppose that these relative interest rate movements would have encouraged the dollar to weaken against sterling and by more against the euro - and given the pattern of international imbalances it would have been helpful if they had.
These adjustments might take place gradually over time, implying a more protracted period of relatively slow growth in the US Or, if you are really pessimistic, you might anticipate more abrupt adjustment, implying a period of negative US growth and global financial instability.
On an optimistic view we may be largely through the sharp downward stock adjustment, and with consumption so far holding up better than generally expected, and with the possibility that investment will recover as the spread of ICT through the economy resumes, US activity may pick up as we move, say, into next year.
These adjustments might take place gradually over time, in which case the US might face a more protracted period of relatively slow growth; or, if you are really pessimistic, the adjustments might be more abrupt implying a possible period of negative growth and global financial instability.
But the pessimist is inclined to point to the weakness of private sector saving, which could induce more cautious consumer behaviour especially if unemployment continues to rise; he points to a possible overhang of past investment excesses; and he points to the US external deficit which will at some point need to be corrected.
We would all agree on the desirability of voluntary solutions, which might be easier to achieve if borrowing countries and their major creditors - above all the short-term lenders - were to establish, during the good times but on an on-going basis, arrangements for regular dialogue.
These adjustments might take place gradually over time, in which case the US might face a more protracted period of relatively slow growth; or, if you are really pessimistic, the adjustments might be more abrupt implying a possible period of negative growth and global financial instability.
But the pessimist is inclined to point to the weakness of private sector saving, which could induce more cautious consumer behaviour especially if unemployment continues to rise; he points to a possible overhang of past investment excesses; and he points to the US external deficit which will at some point need to be corrected.
That is why, even though the economy as a whole continues to perform relatively well on the data, we have moved interest rates downwards this year, to reflect the emergence of the new downside risks; and it is also why we indicated, in our recent press release, that we will continue to monitor those downside risks.
For what it is worth, at the time of our last forecast in November, our central projection - on the assumption of 6% interest rates - was for output growth of around 2½% over the next couple of years, with RPIX inflation remaining modestly below target this year but rising to 2½% in 2002.
But in the meantime it is not at all clear that there is much that we could do - even if we wanted to - to weaken sterling against the euro by marginal changes in short-term interest rates.
The IMF forecast GDP growth of 3.4% in Iran in 2000/01.
Total external debt is expected to decline to around 10% of GDP this year, and short-term debt to only about 40% of reserves, having fallen from around 65% in 1999/2000.
The Chancellor recognised that it was unrealistic to think that a decision could be reached during the lifetime of the present Parliament, which runs to May 2002 at the latest.
But it will need to be accompanied by corresponding moderation of the growth of domestic demand - after the offsetting stimulus of a year ago - if we are to maintain overall stability.
The reality is that if we were to put the economy as a whole at any significant risk of accelerating inflation - notwithstanding our mandate - we would not succeed in providing the intended protection even to the internationally-exposed sectors, except possibly in the very short term; and we would jeopardise the prospect of sustained growth in the economy as …
That does not necessarily mean that we will not see accelerating productivity growth.
And will those of you who think that interest rates should be lower than they are at present now please raise a hand - but remember you can only vote if you agreed that monetary policy should be directed to controlling inflation!
But for the time being, the rate of world output growth, which had fallen to only about 2% in 1998, about half its long-term trend rate, and which was widely expected to fall further, is now expected to bounce back to around trend over the next couple of years.
Well, I can predict that, after two years of new year working, we will all be able to enjoy our New Year's Day bank holiday for a change next year!
Showing the newest 50 - the ledger has all 97.
Also said - not checkable as stated (12 newest)
Remarks about the future with no date, figure or likelihood that could be checked. They are kept on the record and shown here, but not scored.
To Who's He? -| say thank you and farewell until we meet again -as | very much hope we will if ever Vanessa and | manage to tear ourselves away from Cornwall.
To stay on course while those storms persisted we've had to compensate for the external weakness by accepting -indeed positively encouraging through monetary policy -domestic consumer demand growth at a rate that we knew could not be sustained indefinitely.
And I've every confidence that Mervyn King -who has in effect been our Chief Navigating Officer for much of the past decade, and who will take over as skipper at the end of the month, with an outstanding MPC and Bank crew to support him -will find the way through. | certainly wish them safe passage!
We at the Bank have enjoyed tremendous moral and practical -not to mention gastronomical -support in all our efforts to promote the reputation and prosperity of the City, and | hope that you may feel that we have been equally supportive of initiatives that you have taken to the same end.
And | should like to take this opportunity above all to thank all of you -and the various organisations that you represent -for the tremendous support that you have given to me and to the Bank over so many years.
Taken together, these developments should accommodate the moderation in the rate of growth of consumer spending, which we anticipate and may now be beginning to see.
On this basis - and although the MPC will of course be monitoring the inflation prospect very carefully we concluded at our most recent meeting that policy should remain on hold.
Then I held out to you the prospect of continuing stability - with low inflation and sustained economic growth - as far ahead as I could see.
The global economy may not pick up gradually - as we certainly hope that it will - and some real gloomsters still talk of the possibility of a double dip back into recession.
Similarly a sharp rise in interest rates is less likely if consumer spending is slowing down.
But for the most part such regulation today does not tell us what we can and cannot do, rather it sets the criteria that we must meet, and the behavioural standards we are expected to observe, in doing whatever it is that we choose to do.
That approach has not necessarily always been popular, I have to say, with some of those who might have benefited from such discrimination!